Drew
University Writing Instructor Guidelines:
The Library component of English 1 and 2
Library instruction for first
year students occurs in three places and on three levels, which can be
described as follows:
|
First-year seminar: An introduction to the library and
to the process of information retrieval. Students learn what services the
library offers, how to use OAK, and how to locate the texts. The
purpose of this visit is to introduce them to the library in a very concrete
way. |
|
English 1: An introduction to bibliography construction.
Students learn more sophisticated ways to perform library searches, including
using "or" instead of "and" in key word searches, and distinguishing between
data bases. They also learn how to broaden their search so that they
can become more selective in the materials they use and more flexible in
their topic selection (rather than taking the first 3 books from a list
of 20, they will learn to select the most appropriate texts using evaluative
criteria). Students should begin the session with fairly broad topics,
and by the end of the session they will have learned to narrow their topics,
select appropriate sources, and begin to evaluate those sources (they might
move from the general topic "gun control" to the specific topic "the Brady
Bill," and finally toward a thesis concerning the constitutional argument
over the Brady Bill, for example). Working with a member of the
reference staff also increases the students' confidence and gives them
a point of contact within the library for the future.
(See
below for possible models for incorporating this component into your course.) |
|
English 2: An introduction to advanced searching, evaluating,
and bibliography construction. In English 2, instead of the students
going to the library, the library comes to the students in three regularly
scheduled class sessions, usually beginning the second week of classes.
Although at first it seems difficult to give up three class sessions, we
have found that the skills the students learn really enhance their research
and their larger educational experience at Drew. Students need to
have already identified topics for their final research. This allows
them to use the library sessions to practice effective narrowing of focus,
searching and evaluating of sources, and bibliography building. By
the end of the sequence they should have conducted background research,
narrowed their topic, evaluated potential sources and developed a working
bibliography or even an annotated bibliography.
Some students registered for English
2 may have already taken English 1 or completed a writing course elsewhere,
but they will find that the three research sessions in English 2 enhance
what they have already learned, while refreshing and updating what they
may have forgotten.
(See below for possible models for incorporating this
component into your course.) |
Making the library component
successful:
Obviously, the key to the success of this component of the course is
in the hands of the instructors. The students must understand why
they are going to the library, what they should accomplish there, and how
it connects to the overall course. If the English 1 instructor does
not explain this and build the library component into the course, its success
will be limited. We only achieve 100% attendance and attention when
students have an assignment to complete that they know will be graded by
the instructor and that is clearly not "busy work." The annotated
bibliography assignment is one example of this, but obviously instructors
should feel free to design their own assignments and build them into their
own courses as long as they meet the overall goals described above.
There are
three models for the library component of English 1:
|
One-on-one sessions in which each student spends 40-45 minutes with
a member of the reference staff. These allow the students the
most personal experience, but only one class can go a week, so instructors
have less flexibility about when they assign library work. |
|
Small group sessions in which students visit the library in groups
of four. This only works if all group members have exactly the same
topic. The advantage of this model is that it teaches students to
work together, encourages discussion and cooperation, and allows two classes
to complete their library component each week, providing more flexibility
for instructors. However, students who miss the session find it hard
to make up the work. |
|
Large group sessions in which the whole class visits the library
at once. This only works if the
whole class is working on the same topic or type of research.
Students do not receive the individual attention provided in the other
models, but they are introduced to a member of the reference
staff, and they learn the same library skills as they would in smaller
groups. |
There are
three stages to the library component of English 2:
|
The first session deals with effective
searching of the Internet (search engines v directories, etc.), with an
emphasis on developing boolean search statements, and students are asked
to retrieve two web sites pertinent to their topics. |
|
The second session transfers those
skills to one or two general databases such as Academic Search or ProQuest
Direct, and students are again asked to retrieve 2-3 pertinent articles
from those databases. |
|
The websites and articles are then used as examples in the
third session, which focusses on the evaluation of information
sources. |
Topics to avoid:
Whichever method you select, there are a few topics to avoid because
the library lacks sufficient print-based resources to allow the students
to practice research. Amongst those topics are athletics and popular
music (Jody can tell you others if you are unsure how to advise a student).
Students can be steered away from these topics and toward topics we could
provide information about (the topic "the baseball strike," for example,
could become a paper on anti-trust laws, and the topic "rap music" could
become an analysis of sexist language in rap music where the student provides
the song lyrics and uses the library to research sexism in popular culture).
Please contact Jody
Caldwell (x3481) if you have any questions about this component of
English 1, or talk to me if you are unsure how to incorporate this into
your course or motivate students. I'd like to see us
achieve 100% attendance this semester please.
|